Commons:Valued image candidates/Abies koreana (szyszki).JPG

Abies koreana (szyszki).JPG

undecided

Image
Nominated by	Lestat (talk) on 2008-08-19 19:45 (UTC)
Scope	Nominated as the most valued image on Commons within the scope: Abies koreana cone
Used in	Global usage Abies koreana en:Abies koreana en:Fir pl:Jodła koreańska pl:Jodła pl:Szyszka de:Korea-Tanne zh:朝鲜冷杉 ko:구상나무 fr:Sapin fr:Sapin de Corée tr:Köknar tr:Kore köknarı hr:Jele bs:Jela bg:Ела bg:Иглолистни sl:Iglavci sr:Јела eo:Abio ro:Brad ca:Avet es:Abies koreana nl:Koreaanse zilverspar
Review (criteria)	Oppose I find Image:Abies koreana (szyszki) crop.JPG and Image:Abies koreana (poprawione).jpg better suited as they don't show that disturbing bit of background right top. Further more scopes for organisms should IMO always contain the scientific name of the species (or higher taxon when applicable). That could be Abies koreana cone(s) here. Lycaon (talk) 08:24, 23 August 2008 (UTC)  Info I changed the scope. --Lestat (talk) 09:45, 23 August 2008 (UTC)  Comment So, maybe example that You linked are a bit better, but they are only croped or modified version of that I proposed. Now, when main version of this photo is Featured Picture, Quality Picture, Turkish Wikipedia Featured Picture and Picture of the Day I cannot find sense of promoting another version. Additionaly this one is used in many projects. When another version will be VI people will have problem which is better FP+QI+POTY or VI??? --Lestat (talk) 10:03, 23 August 2008 (UTC)  Support I think Lestat is right. Croped version gives no added value. Retouched is not much better. --Sfu (talk) 12:46, 25 August 2008 (UTC)  Neutral It is not that the individual versions are very different, but I actually think Image:Abies koreana (poprawione).jpg is a slightly better illustration of the stated scope (featured on Polish Wikipedia). If that version was properly categorized and geocoded I would support that one in a Most Valued Review. -- Slaunger (talk) 20:20, 26 August 2008 (UTC)  Comment -- I've always loved this picture but must agree with Lycaon and Slaunger: Image:Abies koreana (poprawione).jpg is better -- Alvesgaspar (talk) 09:17, 27 August 2008 (UTC) Result: 1 support, 1 neutral, 1 oppose => Undecided. -- Slaunger (talk) 21:28, 29 August 2008 (UTC)